Can A Property Owner Block An Easement

Blocked driveways, fences, and utility shutoffs can turn a calm morning into a property crisis; that moment sparks the question: Can a property owner block an easement? In plain terms, a landowner generally cannot lawfully obstruct a valid and legally established easement, and courts can order removal of barriers and impose remedies for interference. At Shapero Law Firm, your San Francisco Real Estate Lawyer, after we verify what your records and history show, we act quickly and with precision to restore access.

Understanding Easements on Your Property

An easement is a nonpossessory right to use another person’s land for a defined purpose. The land benefiting from the right is the dominant tenement, and the land burdened by it is the servient estate. Because the right concerns use, not ownership, efforts to terminate or obstruct access can trigger claims for injunctive relief, declaratory relief, or damages.

In California, the holder of an appurtenant easement can bring an action to enforce that right under California Civil Code section 809, which recognizes enforcement by the owner or occupant of the dominant tenement. For practical real estate planning, understanding whether the easement is recorded, implied by prior use, by necessity, or acquired by prescription is essential.

Common questions that are address include: Who maintains the easement area, can gates be added with shared keys, and what qualifies as unreasonable interference. In San Francisco, tight lots and older utility corridors make clarity on scope, width, and maintenance obligations critical for avoiding right-of-way disputes.

Types of Easements

California recognizes many categories, including rights-of-way, utility corridors, and certain rights to take or discharge resources. The statutory list of recognized interests identified in California Civil Code section 801 includes rights of way, the right of receiving air, light, or heat from or over land, the right of receiving or discharging water, the right of taking water, wood, minerals, and other things, the right of using a wall as a party wall, and other specified uses.

Other concepts often raised in real estate litigation include licenses versus easements, equitable servitudes, and prescriptive easements in California, which require open, notorious, continuous, and adverse use for the statutory period. Title reports, historic aerials, survey maps, and neighbor communications often supply the evidence that proves or defeats claimed rights.

415-906-6134

TALK TO AN ATTORNEY TODAY

How to Modify or Remove an Easement

Changing or eliminating an easement typically occurs through one of four paths:

• Written agreement and recordation, with all affected owners signing and the instrument recorded in the county land records.
• Abandonment, shown by clear nonuse coupled with conduct inconsistent with continuing rights.
• Merger occurs when the dominant and servient parcels come under the same ownership.
• A court order, usually via quiet title or declaratory judgment, to confirm, modify, or extinguish the easement.

Before taking action, identify if the issue is safety, noise, parking, or a legal access concern. Mediation can achieve practical solutions such as scheduled use, shared maintenance, or controlled gate installations.

However, can a property owner block an easement? Actions such as locking a gate without providing access or temporarily parking vehicles to block a driveway risk legal repercussions. This could lead to a preliminary injunction, attorney’s fees if provided by agreement or statute, and a court order restoring access. It is advisable to document conditions with photos, maintain communication records, and retain a surveyor if boundaries or widths are unclear.

What to Do If You’re in an Easement Dispute

Start with this concise checklist to confirm the easement, capture interference, and set up your next legal steps:

• Pull the current title report
• Gather any recorded maps or deeds
• Locate old surveys
• Collect photos showing historic use

Next, send a precise, professional demand that describes the easement location, width, and purpose, and requests immediate removal of obstructions. If the other party refuses, consider mediation with a neutral who understands property rights.

In case obstructions continue, legal options include a quiet title action to confirm the easement, injunctive relief to stop interference, and, where appropriate, damages for loss of use. Emergency relief may be available if blocked access endangers safety or essential utility service. Throughout this process, maintain consistent terminology so your evidence reads clearly.

How Can Shapero Law Firm Help in San Francisco?

Get your driveway open and your plans back on track. At Shapero Law Firm, we handle easement disputes across San Francisco with fast assessment, precise filings, and practical solutions. To clearly answer the common question: Can a property owner block an easement? Call us at 415-906-6134 today to start your consultation and restore your right-of-way while protecting your property’s value.

Client Reviews

What our clients are saying about us

I contacted Sarah when I was facing tough legal issues. Although I never met her in person she ended up being an amazing advocate, tough negotiator and very knowledgeable representation. In all my communication Sarah was clear, thorough and very neutral about my position and options. I’ve had multiple dealings with attorneys…so I’m experienced. I would give Sarah top ratings across the board.

Deborah Tamburri

View More Reviews on Google Maps and Yelp